Jszostak's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Walking the Walk]

silky smooth

A lot of nice cycles here. Fav is the laid back red cat. Lov your work. Hope to see some more story based stuff again soon...

TheBoogley responds:

one of these days maybe a story will come... :)

[A Letter from God]

certain aspects were great others need improvement

To be honest this animation seemed halfway finished. the lyrics were great and the music was above par. but the actual physical animation was a little lacking. More detail and more colour i feel would push this flash to better heights. this is but one opinion, however i have done animation and i am no pro, but i feel there is some richness that is lacking especially when combo'd with the great lyrics of the song

Lankie responds:

ah indeed. I spose the lack of colour was an a choice I made, making it mostly black and red...then again there are little bits of colour in it anyway. Thabnks for the review!

[Abeyance: Audition]

really nice flash.

i really liked that, you really put some time into this. great job.

now with that being said, this flash doesnt seem know what it is, is it a funny flash? a serious flash? or a serious flash with comic releif every now and then. i think its more of the latter, however it didnt seem to quite make that jump yet. the art style is VERY cartoony. which i think is a very good thing. i just think you need to push the humor a little harder. keep this overall serious tone that redhead has, and push the sillyness of the wierd little scientists a little harder. maybe even the scientists in his flashbacks. i think the word "wierd" is what you should be pushing a little more. OR if you disagree then go in whatever direction you feel woulld better it. either way i feel that this flash (series?) needs to be pushed harder one way or the other.

Calicard responds:

Thanks.

I do want it to be serious with some comic relief.

So Ill just push the levels of each a little higher.

Thanks for the review!

["trick or treat?"]

hahahaha

ok.. so first of all, you gotta respect the effort you put into those movie clips.... then the actual character movement is just so dedicated... you can really feel the disipline your have for yourself..

I obviously loved the animation, just one more step into the cave of Neil Sanders psychotic imagery, and yes, i will go on

TheBoogley responds:

there's a light in there somewhere towards the back of the cave, keep going

[Compilation Jun'07-Apr'08]

prolific!

you sir are rediculous. Do you do all of the voice work? everything looks so retro for some reason... i can definatley see why you would be invited to show this to a large audience. KEEP THIS SHIT UP!

TheBoogley responds:

I did do all the voices, and I had a lot of fun experimenting with different techniques, thanks :D

[Skull in Connemara]

oh wow fuckin cool style

i was like TheBoogley?? that sounds familiar, then i said, withholing my gasp, this guy reviewed me!!!

that was a fuckin sick style you pulled off there... i dont know anything about the play or whatever footage from the film(if there was one?) that you took from, but man when we was walkin through the woods, you really pulled off that black and white thing.. really like ho you went back in with black to, just great man, 10 and 5

TheBoogley responds:

I filmed one of the actors in our play to work from, it wasn't from a movie.
I'm glad you liked it, thanks for the review :)

[GUN & SWORD]

seriousness on

wow and what a fucking end it is... i remeber watching solid sticks years ago and being totally inspired by them... your progress is truly startling...

I think everyone (if they haven't already) should go back and watch the first 5 episodes... i mean if you loved this animation then you owe it to the animator to see how this series has evolved... plus the other episodes are freakin cool anyways!

great job xarugas03!

xarugas03 responds:

im glad my works inspired you dude, and thanks for the support on them all! :D

[Out of Reach]

as disturbing as Salo

im reminded of 120 days of sodom...

LMFAO to the last review and responce

uhhmmmm.... it was... what it was... you know what it was, because it was what it was from what you felt it was going to be

Joelasticool responds:

It's an hongargojgoagagjagpaojgaj

[Toothpaste]

wtf

i got a black screen with voices... daily feature, ill give you a 9 just on that

Freemont responds:

Ha-ha!!! That review just made my day.

You need Flash 8 man!

[Zookeeper Rampage]

nice 4 1st but

shotguns give off spurts of light, when hes shooting in the dark there needs to be shots of light from each blast, in each shti he should be in a different place and a different position, then this would be a solid piece, you should fix that and then just update this file...ill check back soon or just email me if you do it...plokijuh2@hotmail . com

rcu49p9gz responds:

Yeah, that would have been cool, but I think that I will just leave it as it is. There is some other stuff I would have liked to ad (better walking animation). If I do a second movie like this, I'll be sure to put in extra stuff like that. Thanks a lot for the tip. It is most appreciated.